I know you hate when I say this but to me this sounds very normal.
Integration takes time. Awareness is the key.
I had a similar experience with a gratitude practice earlier in my journey. I knew intellectually that I have a good life and many things to be happy about. I had a hard time though feeling it or being in a positive place. I just felt flat and lacked any ability to sustain any optimism. But I kept at it, every day writing down 3 things, and after a while I started noticing things to write the next day. And then I just started noticing things more and more until it was pretty much all the time.
Not the same scenario you have written here. But what we notice expands.
You have started to nurture your relationship with yourself. Some of this is coming from you changing behaviors that ultimately was bringing you down. Doing that for yourself made you feel the ability to appreciate yourself more. This is a great realization, and I have found the more we do good, the more we feel good, the more we feel good, the more we want to do good.
So exorcising things like contributing to the spiral of conversations (and other things that was in that recent plan you shared) freed up more time to feel good. Getting bigger down in fighting about things that get so convoluted that you lose track of what matters is a huge energy drain. Those are the things that were actually working against you in your relationship with yourself. Instead, you made a plan to expand on the good for yourself.
All good steps, and it didn’t come at once. It came after you gained self awareness.
Now you have a new awareness, and over time you will stop looking for proof of no love and switch it to proof of love. You couldn’t do that as fully until the awareness of it happened.
For me, once I realized that some of my narratives about my husband not loving me or providing me with emotional security were really mostly products of how I was taking in the data rather than the true data itself, this did start to turn around. It takes time but it’s not something you have to struggle with yourself about. You just simply need to pay attention more and appreciate as it’s happening.
I suspect I have ADHD as well, and I too loved chaos. But sleeping down and noticing, being mindful, this naturally (mostly) slowly left the building.
The power is in the narratives a s the stories you tell yourself. Just slow down and really notice what is happening and appreciating more and that narrative will slowly change.
Congratulations—-this is a bigger turning point for you than you realize yet.